Currently seriously considering building my own PC as my current laptop is now broken. My question is to what degree should I trust reviews on sites like Newegg? It always worries me when I see the most helpful review is one that isn't good. However this often happens on things where the 5 and 4 eggs far out weigh the 1 and 2 eggs. So do I trust the majority or the people who've experienced the problems?

Write Answer

buildapc

avatar
Celicam
4 Answers
Contributor
19 people found this helpful

I would set up a parts list and then ask around here for opinons.

Was this answer helpful? Helpful
Contributor
10 people found this helpful

Trust some of the reviews, but keep in mind that someone is more likely to write a spiteful review if their product is broken than they are to write a good review if their product is working.

That's why many motherboard reviews have ~ 60% 4 and 5 egg reviews and ~ 30% 1 egg reviews.

Was this answer helpful? Helpful
Contributor
6 people found this helpful

I would ignore any review that says "THIS PRODUCT WAS DOA DO NOT BUY IT!!!!" because the place you bought it from will likely replace it right away. I would trust professional sites like Anandtech.com as well.

Was this answer helpful? Helpful
Contributor
9 people found this helpful

I generally just take the reviews with a grain of salt. Make sure you read the review instead of just looking at the rating. Some of them are well done and have good reasoning. A lot of the 1 eggs are people who just got one that was doa, which happens with almost any part.

Was this answer helpful? Helpful
Community Rules
Narfar is a diverse community of product enthusiasts. It is fine to disagree or share opinions, but please remain constructive and refrain from being rude to others. We have a zero tolerance policy against offensive behavior.